COURT INDEX AND DOCKET

  
  
RECORDED ENTRY(IES) FOR T-1500-08 (Close)
  
Court Number : T-1500-08
Style of Cause : DUFF CONACHER ET AL v. THE PRIME MINISTER OF CANADA ET AL
Proceeding Category : Applications Nature : S. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review
Type of Action : Non-Action
 
( 87 records found )
Doc Date Filed Office Recorded Entry Summary
- 2010-05-25 Ottawa Copy of Reasons for Judgment and Judgment dated 25-MAY-2010 rendered by The Honourable Mr. Justice Létourneau The Honourable Madam Justice Layden-Stevenson The Honourable Mr. Justice Stratas placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. A-427-09
63 2010-01-08 Ottawa Traduction certifiée conforme (texte français) des motifs du jugement et jugement rendus le 17-SEP-2009 par Monsieur le juge Shore déposée le 08-JAN-2010 en vertu de l'article 20 de la Loi sur les langues officielles Certificat de la traduction du jugement inscrit(e) dans le livre J. & O., volume 1076 page(s) 229 - 229 et placé au dossier.
- 2009-10-27 Ottawa Copy of Notice of Appeal (Appeal Court File No. A-427-09 ) appealing the Order of Mr. Justice Shore dated 17-SEP-2009; filed in the Court of Appeal on 15-OCT-2009 on behalf of Appellant placed on file on 27-OCT-2009
62 2009-09-17 Ottawa Reasons for Judgment and Judgment dated 17-SEP-2009 rendered by The Honourable Mr. Justice Shore Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Judicial Review (s.18) Result: dismissed THIS COURT ORDERS that the application of the Applicants be denied, however, without costs due to the nature of the proceeding which necessitated that the separation of powers, on the issues in question, be explained for the understanding of the public. Filed on 17-SEP-2009 certified copies sent to parties Final Decision Certificate of Judgment entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1065 page(s) 333 - 333
- 2009-09-08 Ottawa List of Exhibits on behalf of Applicant received at hearing on 08-SEP-2009
- 2009-09-08 Ottawa Ottawa 08-SEP-2009 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Shore Language: E Before the Court: Judicial Review Result of Hearing: Matter reserved held in Court Senior Usher: J. Charlebois Y. Claude Duration per day: 08-SEP-2009 from 09:35 to 05:44 Courtroom : East Courtroom - Ottawa Court Registrar: Colinne Martin Total Duration: 8h 9 min Appearances: Mr. Peter Rosenthal (416) 657-1465 representing Applicant Mr. Robert MacKinnon (613) 957-4857 representing Respondent Ms. Catherine Lawrence (613) 957-4857 representing Respondent Ms, Agniezka Zagorska (613) 957-4857 representing Respondent Documents filed at hearing: 60 61 Exhibits filed at hearing: A1-A4 Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 808 page(s) 89 - 103 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
61 2009-09-08 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Natalee Brouse sworn on 13-JUL-2009 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of doc. no. 60 upon Respondent and all provincial Attorneys General by telecopier on 09-JUL-2009 confirming service doc. no. 60 upon Attorneys General by telecopier on 10-JUL-2009 with Exhibits A-O filed on 08-SEP-2009
60 2009-09-08 Ottawa Amended Notice of a constitutional question on behalf of Applicant filed on 08-SEP-2009
59 2009-05-26 Ottawa Order (time and place) dated 26-MAY-2009 rendered by Chief Justice Lutfy and signed by Judicial Administrator fixing Judicial Review (s.18) to be heard at Special Sitting in Ottawa on 08-SEP-2009 to begin at 09:30 duration: 1d language: E Filed on 26-MAY-2009 cc's sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1055 page(s) 138 - 138 Transmittal letters placed on file
- 2009-05-21 Ottawa Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 21-MAY-2009 re: requesting that a date for the JR be set down, per Requsition for Hearing doc. no. 57, filed 20-MAY-2009.
58 2009-05-20 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Duff Conacher sworn on 20-MAY-2009 on behalf of applicants confirming service of Doc#57 upon respondents by personal service on 20-MAY-2009 filed on 20-MAY-2009
57 2009-05-20 Ottawa Requisition for hearing - Application from applicants filed on 20-MAY-2009 Tariff Application or appeal - $50.00
- 2009-05-11 Ottawa Covering letter from Respondent dated 11-MAY-2009 concerning Doc. Nos. 54 55 56 placed on file on 11-MAY-2009
56 2009-05-11 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Jennae O'Connor sworn on 11-MAY-2009 on behalf of Respondent with consent to extend the time for filing confirming service of Respondents' Record (Doc 55) upon Applicant by courier on 11-MAY-2009 filed on 11-MAY-2009
55 2009-05-11 Ottawa Respondent's Record (3 Vols) Number of copies received/prepared: 3 on behalf of Respondent with consent to extend the time for filing filed on 11-MAY-2009
54 2009-05-11 Ottawa Consent on behalf of Applicant to 10 day extension of time (Rule 7) for filing Respondents' Record. filed on 11-MAY-2009
53 2009-04-09 Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Yavar Hameed confirming service of doc.52 upon Respondent by process server on 09-APR-2009 filed on 09-APR-2009
52 2009-04-09 Ottawa Applicant's Record (5 volumes) Number of copies received/prepared: 3 on behalf of Applicant with consent to extend the time for filing filed on 09-APR-2009 Document placed in Annexes C D
51 2009-04-09 Ottawa Consent on behalf of Respondent to 10 day extension to file Applicant's Record filed on 09-APR-2009
50 2009-02-23 Ottawa Order dated 23-FEB-2009 rendered by Mireille Tabib, Prothonotary Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion in writing Doc. No. 45 Result: It is ordered that: 1. The time within which the parties are to complete cross-examinations is extended to March 13, 2009. Filed on 23-FEB-2009 certified copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1047 page(s) 291 - 291 Interlocutory Decision
- 2009-02-17 Ottawa Covering letter from Respondent dated 17-FEB-2009 concerning Doc. Nos. 48 49 placed on file on 17-FEB-2009
49 2009-02-17 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Melanie Dubeau sworn on 17-FEB-2009 on behalf of Respondent confirming service of 48 upon Applicant by courier on 17-FEB-2009 filed on 17-FEB-2009
48 2009-02-17 Ottawa Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 45 46 47 Number of copies received: 3 on behalf of Respondent filed on 17-FEB-2009
47 2009-02-17 Ottawa Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent concerning Motion Doc. No. 45 filed on 17-FEB-2009
46 2009-02-17 Ottawa Affidavit of Angieszka Zagorska sworn on 17-FEB-2009 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in support of Motion Doc. No. 45 with Exhibits ** A ** - with consent of Applicants filed on 17-FEB-2009
45 2009-02-17 Ottawa Notice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in writing to be dealt with in the Ottawa local office for an extension of time until March 13, 2009 to complete the cross- examination of the affiants in this Application filed on 17-FEB-2009 Draft Order\\Judgment received.
- 2009-01-12 Ottawa Covering letter from Respondents dated 12-JAN-2009 concerning Doc. Nos. 42 43 44 placed on file on 12-JAN-2009
44 2009-01-12 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Kamal Dean sworn on 12-JAN-2009 on behalf of Respondents confirming service of Docs: 42-43 upon applicants by courier on 12-JAN-2009 filed on 12-JAN-2009
43 2009-01-12 Ottawa Affidavit of John C. Courtney sworn on 08-JAN-2009 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-F filed on 12-JAN-2009
42 2009-01-12 Ottawa Affidavit of Patrick J. Monahan sworn on 19-DEC-2008 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-B-C filed on 12-JAN-2009
41 2009-01-12 Ottawa Consent on behalf of applicants to Respondent's Affidavit filed on 12-JAN-2009
40 2008-12-12 Ottawa Order dated 12-DEC-2008 rendered by Mireille Tabib, Prothonotary Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 34 Result: granted Filed on 12-DEC-2008 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1041 page(s) 466 - 467 Interlocutory Decision
- 2008-12-10 Ottawa Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 10-DEC-2008 re: Applicant's Motion Record on consent sent to Court (Doc.38)
39 2008-12-05 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Duff Conacher sworn on 05-DEC-2008 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Doc 38 upon Respondent by personal service on 05-DEC-2008 with Exhibits A filed on 05-DEC-2008
38 2008-12-05 Ottawa Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 34 35 36 Number of copies received: 3 on behalf of Applicant filed on 05-DEC-2008
37 2008-12-05 Ottawa Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant concerning Motion Doc. No. 34 filed on 05-DEC-2008
36 2008-12-05 Ottawa Consent on behalf of Respondent to doc 34 filed on 05-DEC-2008
35 2008-12-05 Ottawa Affidavit of Duff Conacher sworn on 03-DEC-2008 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in support of Motion Doc. No. 34 filed on 05-DEC-2008
34 2008-12-05 Ottawa Notice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in writing to be placed before the Court in Ottawa for for an order that the judicial review of the three actions or decision impugned in the Notice of Application be consolidated together in this single application for judicial review. filed on 05-DEC-2008
32 2008-11-12 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Duff Conacher sworn on 12-NOV-2008 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of document no. 31 upon Respondent by personal service on 12-NOV-2008 filed on 12-NOV-2008
31 2008-11-12 Ottawa Affidavit of professor Errol P. Mendes sworn on 12-NOV-2008 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits a filed on 12-NOV-2008
28 2008-11-10 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Duff Conacher sworn on 10-NOV-2008 on behalf of Applicants confirming service of Document #27 upon all parties by personal service on 10-NOV-2008 with Exhibits a filed on 10-NOV-2008
27 2008-11-10 Ottawa Affidavit of John Bennett sworn on 10-NOV-2008 on behalf of Applicants in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 filed on 10-NOV-2008
33 2008-11-06 Ottawa Affidavit of service of ? sworn on 06-NOV-2008 on behalf of applicants confirming service of Aff of Duff Conacher, Aff of Sinclair Mcknight Stevens, Aff of Sebastien Thériautl, Aff of Amanda Judd, Aff of Gail Florence, Aff of Lawrence upon Respondents by personal service on 06-NOV-2008 filed on 06-NOV-2008
30 2008-11-06 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Catherine Chhina sworn on 30-SEP-2008 on behalf of applicants confirming service of Doc.29 upon Attorney General of Canada at (613) 9907255 Attorney General of Alberta Depatment of Justice at (780)422-6621 Attorney General of British Columbia at (205)387-6411 Attorney General of Manitoba at (204)945-2517 Attorney General of New Brunswick; Department of Justice at (506) 444-2661 Attorney Genearl fo Newfoundland at (709) 729-2129 Attorney General of the Northwest Territories at (827) 873-0306 Attorney General of Nova Scotia at (902) 424-7596 Attorney General of Nunavut; Department of Justice at (867) 975-6195 Attorney General of Ontario at (416) 326-4007 Attorney General of Prince Edward Island at (902) 368-4910 Attorney General of Quebec at (418) 646-0027 Attorney General of Yukon; Deprtment of Justice at (867) 393-6379 by telecopier on 26-SEP-2008 with Exhibits A-B filed on 06-NOV-2008
29 2008-11-06 Ottawa Notice of a constitutional question on behalf of applicants filed on 06-NOV-2008
26 2008-11-06 Ottawa Affidavit of Duff Conacher sworn on 30-SEP-2008 on behalf of applicants with consent to extend the time for filing in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-M filed on 06-NOV-2008
25 2008-11-06 Ottawa Affidavit of Peter H. Russell sworn on 21-OCT-2008 on behalf of applicants with consent to extend the time for filing in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A filed on 06-NOV-2008
24 2008-11-06 Ottawa Affidavit of Lawrence LeDuc sworn on 27-SEP-2008 on behalf of applicants with consent to extend the time for filing in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A filed on 06-NOV-2008
23 2008-11-06 Ottawa Affidavit of Gail Florence Nestel sworn on 17-OCT-2008 on behalf of applicants with consent to extend the time for filing in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-c filed on 06-NOV-2008
22 2008-11-06 Ottawa Affidavit of Amanda Judd sworn on 31-OCT-2008 on behalf of applicants with consent to extend the time for filing in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 filed on 06-NOV-2008
21 2008-11-06 Ottawa Affidavit of Sebastien Theriault sworn on 23-OCT-2008 on behalf of applicants with consent to extend the time for filing in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 filed on 06-NOV-2008
20 2008-11-06 Ottawa Affidavit of Sinclair Mcknight Stevens sworn on 05-NOV-2008 on behalf of Applicants with consent to extend the time for filing in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 filed on 06-NOV-2008
- 2008-10-29 Ottawa Covering letter from Respondent dated 29-OCT-2008 concerning Doc. Nos. 19 placed on file on 29-OCT-2008
- 2008-10-29 Ottawa Certified copy of original material received from Privy Council's Office on 29-OCT-2008 placed on file on this file
19 2008-10-29 Ottawa Consent on behalf of Applicant to a 10 day extension for the Respondent's to file Tribunal Record filed on 29-OCT-2008
18 2008-10-23 Ottawa Consent on behalf of Respondent to an extension of time for an additional 15 days for the Applicants to serve and file their Affidavits filed on 23-OCT-2008
- 2008-10-07 Ottawa Memorandum to file from Audrey Boucher dated 07-OCT-2008 spoke to Counsel for the Attorney General admitting service of Notice of Application on September 30, 2008 placed on file.
15 2008-10-03 Ottawa Reasons for Order and Order dated 03-OCT-2008 rendered by Roza Aronovitch, Prothonotary Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 6 Result: granted The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 2 Result: -The Attorney Genearl is added as respondent to the application without prejudice to the right of the respondents to object to the propriety of naming the Prime Minister of Canada, the Governor General and the Governor in Council as respondents; - The Applicants' motion to expedite the hearing of the application on the merits on October 8 or 9, 2008, is denied, with costs Filed on 03-OCT-2008 certified copies sent to parties Transmittal Letters placed on file. Interlocutory Decision Certificate of Order entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1035 page(s) 200 - 200
- 2008-10-02 Ottawa Covering letter from Respondent dated 02-OCT-2008 concerning Doc. Nos. 16 17 placed on file on 02-OCT-2008
17 2008-10-02 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Kamal Dean sworn on 02-OCT-2008 on behalf of Respondent confirming service of document no. 16 upon Applicant by telecopier on 02-OCT-2008 filed on 02-OCT-2008
16 2008-10-02 Ottawa Notice of appearance on behalf of Respondent filed on 02-OCT-2008
- 2008-10-02 Ottawa Document entitled "On statutory interpretation" containing case law on behalf of the Applicants received at hearing on 02-OCT-2008
- 2008-10-02 Ottawa Ottawa 02-OCT-2008 BEFORE Roza Aronovitch, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Motion Doc. No. 6 on behalf of Applicant Result of Hearing: Matter granted Before the Court: Motion Doc. No. 2 on behalf of Applicant Result of Hearing: Matter reserved held in Court Senior Usher: P. Gendron Duration per day: 02-OCT-2008 from 09:38 to 10:55 Courtroom : Courtroom No. 2, 7th Floor - Thomas D'Arcy McGee Bldg. - Ottawa Court Registrar: Colinne Martin Total Duration: 1h 17 min Appearances: Mr. Peter Rosenthal (416) 657-1465 representing Applicant Mr. Christopher Rupar (613) 941-2351 representing Respondent Comments: Document entitled "On statutory interpretation" containing case law submitted by the Applicant. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 785 page(s) 265 - 274 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
14 2008-10-01 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Duff Conacher sworn on 01-OCT-2008 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Volume 2 of doc. 11 upon Respondent and the Attorney General of Canada by personal service on 01-OCT-2008 filed on 01-OCT-2008
- 2008-10-01 Ottawa Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 01-OCT-2008 re: doc. nos. 2, 6 and 13
- 2008-10-01 Ottawa Covering letter from Respondent dated 01-OCT-2008 concerning proof of service to be attached to doc. 13 placed on file on 01-OCT-2008
- 2008-10-01 Ottawa Covering letter from Respondent dated 01-OCT-2008 concerning Doc. No. 13 placed on file on 01-OCT-2008
13 2008-10-01 Ottawa Motion Record in response to Motion Doc. No. 2 containing the following original document(s): 12 Number of copies received: 3 on behalf of Respondent filed on 01-OCT-2008 with proof of service on Applicant on 01-OCT-2008
12 2008-10-01 Ottawa Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent concerning Motion Doc. No. 2 filed on 01-OCT-2008
11 2008-10-01 Ottawa Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 7 8 9 10 Number of copies received: 3 on behalf of Applicant (2 volumes) filed on 01-OCT-2008
10 2008-10-01 Ottawa Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant concerning Motion Doc. No. 2 filed on 01-OCT-2008
9 2008-10-01 Ottawa Affidavit of Errol P. Mendes sworn on 29-SEP-2008 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in support of Motion Doc. No. 2 with Exhibits A filed on 01-OCT-2008
8 2008-10-01 Ottawa Affidavit of Lawrence Leduc sworn on 27-SEP-2008 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in support of Motion Doc. No. 2 with Exhibits A filed on 01-OCT-2008
7 2008-10-01 Ottawa Affidavit of Duff Conacher sworn on 30-SEP-2008 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in support of Motion Doc. No. 2 with Exhibits A-M filed on 01-OCT-2008
- 2008-10-01 Ottawa Correction to General Sitting concerning Motion Doc. No. 6 Hearing added to General Sitting at Ottawa on 02-OCT-2008 at 09:30 duration: 1h Language: E Reason for correction: Hearing information in Recorded Entry made on 01-OCT-2008 had been entered in error.
- 2008-10-01 Ottawa Oral directions received from the presiding judge dated 01-OCT-2008 directing that "The Notice of Motion, without a full motion record, attempted to be filed on behalf of the applicants, pursuant to Rule 369, for an extension of time to file the applicants' motion to expedite the hearing of the underlying application is to be accepted for filing. The requirement for a motion record is hereby waived. The Notice of Motion will constitute the applicants' submissions on the motion to extend time. The motion to expedite the hearing of the application on the merits is to be accepted for filing and placed on the roll for General Sittings on October 2, 2008, subject to the motion to extend time being granted. Both motions will be heard on October 2, 2008, commencing with the motion to extend time." placed on file on 01-OCT-2008
5 2008-10-01 Ottawa Service copy of Doc. No. 1 with proof of service upon the Deputy General of Canada on 30-SEP-2008 filed on 01-OCT-2008
- 2008-10-01 Ottawa Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 01-OCT-2008 re: Request for Directions for Notice of Motion rec'd 30-SEP-2008
- 2008-10-01 Ottawa Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 01-OCT-2008 re: Motion doc. 2
6 2008-10-01 Ottawa Notice of Motion on behalf of Applicant returnable at General Sitting in Ottawa on 02-OCT-2008 to begin at 09:30 duration: 1h language: E for an extension of time to file the Applicants' record for their Motion to be heard by the Court on Thursday October 2, 2008, or in the alternative, the Court to approve under Rule 362(2)(b), the hearing on less than two days notice of the Applicants' Motion for an expedited hearing of their application because of the urgency of the Motion. filed on 01-OCT-2008
4 2008-09-30 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Duff Conacher sworn on 30-SEP-2008 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of the Notice of Motion received 30-SEP-2008 upon Respondent by personal service on 30-SEP-2008 filed on 30-SEP-2008
- 2008-09-29 Ottawa Written directions received from the Court: The Honourable Mr. Justice Lemieux dated 29-SEP-2008 directing that In my view this application must be filed. It is not up to the Court to raise a question of the Court's jurisdiction it is up to the Respondents. Unless this application breaches the Court's rules in term of procedure i.e. contrary to the Rules it must be filed." placed on file on 29-SEP-2008
3 2008-09-29 Ottawa Affidavit of service of Duff Conacher sworn on 29-SEP-2008 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Doc 2 upon Respondent by personal service on 29-SEP-2008 with Exhibits A filed on 29-SEP-2008
2 2008-09-29 Ottawa Notice of Motion on behalf of Applicant returnable at General Sitting in Ottawa on 02-OCT-2008 to begin at 09:30 duration: 1h 59min language: E for 1. An expedited hearing of the Application on its merits in Ottawa on October 8 or 9, 2008 and variation of such Rules as are required to permit the hearing on one of those dates; 2. To add the Attorney General of Canada as a Respondent and; 3. Costs of this motion. filed on 29-SEP-2008
- 2008-09-26 Ottawa Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 26-SEP-2008 re: Notice of Application for Judicial Review
1 2008-09-26 Ottawa Notice of application and 2 copies with regard to Judicial Review (s.18) filed on 26-SEP-2008 Certified copy(ies)/copy(ies) transmitted to Deputy Attorney General of Canada Tariff fee of $50.00 received: yes
The last database update occurred on 2010-07-30 13:48

Top of page